Don Tucker is a trial lawyer with 35 years of complex commercial litigation experience, including significant experience in mergers and acquisition-related litigation, multi-party cases, class actions, claims under the federal securities laws, shareholder and partnership disputes and contract disputes of many types. In Chambers USA, clients say Don is "a really thoughtful and persuasive courtroom lawyer." He has represented a wide variety of corporations, including large public utilities, pharmaceutical and other life sciences companies; contract research organizations; financial institutions and insurance companies; issuers of securities; corporate trustees; directors and officers; professional advisors; agricultural cooperatives; and buyers and sellers of both businesses and of goods and services. Don appears frequently in the North Carolina Business Court where many of the above types of cases are litigated.
Professional & Community Affiliations
- Past Member, Chief Justice's Commission on the Future of the North Carolina Business Court
- Wake County Bar Association
- Member, Chris Episcopal Church
- Step-Up Ministries, Former Co-Partner
- Former Board Member, Artspace
- Former Board Member, Duke Children’s Hospital National Board of Advisors
- Former Board Member, Duke Medical Center Board of Visitors
- Former Board Member, Teach for America, Eastern North Carolina Regional Advisory Board
- Former Board Member, Triangle Family Services
Honors & Awards
- Best Lawyers®, Bet-the-Company Litigation, Commercial Litigation, Litigation - Mergers & Acquisitions, Litigation - Securities (2006-2022)
- Best Lawyers®, "Lawyer of the Year," Raleigh Litigation - Securities (2021)
- Benchmark Litigation, North Carolina Litigation Star (2010-2022)
- Chambers USA: America’s Leading Lawyers for Business, Litigation: General Commercial (2016-2018, 2021-2022)
- Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent Rated
- North Carolina Super Lawyers (2006-2019)
The following are a few of the recent matters that Don has handled for the firm:
- Represented one of the nation’s largest public utilities in complex contract litigation involving a long-term supply contract. Obtained a favorable judgment on an important remedies provision of the agreement after a bench trial before the North Carolina Business Court.
- Represented a large US tobacco manufacturer in shareholder appraisal litigation arising out of a multi-billion merger with the company’s largest shareholder. Served as North Carolina trial counsel in a two-week trial before the North Carolina Business Court to determine the “fair value” of the dissenting shareholders’ shares.
- Represented a large national convenience store operator in environmental and contract litigation arising out of the sale of a gas station. Obtained a favorable judgment after a two-week jury trial in NC state court.
- Represented a life sciences company in connection with disputes arising under various technology licensing agreements.
- Defended independent directors of a Delaware corporation headquartered in Raleigh against challenges to an "exclusive forum" bylaw requiring certain shareholder suits to be brought only in North Carolina. In a precedent-setting opinion that has garnered National attention, the Delaware Court of Chancery ruled in favor of the directors and upheld the bylaw.
- Represented a U.S. pharmaceutical company in post-merger indemnity claim for breach of seller's representations and warranties.
- Defended a public utility company and its directors, as co-counsel, in multiple putative shareholder class actions brought in the North Carolina Business Court challenging multi-billion-dollar merger transaction.
- Defended a public pharmaceutical company and its directors, as co-counsel, in putative shareholder class action filed to enjoin client's merger with another global pharmaceutical company. The defense team successfully defeated plaintiff's motion for preliminary injunction prior to the shareholder vote approving the merger.
- Defended a public company client in a putative shareholder derivative action filed in the federal court for the Eastern District of North Carolina. The lawsuit alleged that the company and its directors breached their fiduciary duties in connection with the “say on pay” provisions of the Dodd-Frank Act. All claims were dismissed with prejudice.
- Represented a global pharmaceutical services company in connection with claims arising out of the termination of a drug co-promotion agreement.
- Advised an international health care group in an agreement to acquire worldwide patent rights and related intellectual property for two cardiovascular drugs from a world leader in biopharmaceutical business.
- Defended a client against claims for breach of an alleged long-term requirements contract brought by a cooperative of independent soft drink bottlers. The case was resolved by confidential settlement after a week-long trial in federal court for the District of South Carolina.
- Defended a leading technology company client as co-counsel in 19 securities fraud class actions consolidated in federal court for the Middle District of North Carolina. The Fourth Circuit affirmed the dismissal of the case, establishing important precedent on the issue of loss causation in securities fraud cases.
- Represented a global pharmaceutical services company in arbitration involving dispute over post-closing price adjustment in the sale of a business division. Obtained significant award in favor of our client after trial before arbitrator.
- Represented a seller of regional supply company in a multi-million-dollar claim against the purchaser of the company for significant post-closing compensation and benefits owed to the seller’s chief executive officer under the terms of the parties’ purchase agreement. Seller agreed to pay full amount of client’s claim prior to the filing of litigation.
- Advised a global solid state LED lighting and semiconductor manufacturing company in connection with the risk aspects of its announced agreement for its $850 million sale of assets to a publicly traded German semiconductor company. The transaction was terminated before completion due to regulatory considerations.
- Don also counsels clients to identify, evaluate, avoid, and manage risk in a variety of corporate and commercial contexts.
News & Publications
- Chambers USA, 06.03.2022
- Smith Anderson Adds a Future Litigation Star to Its 2022 Benchmark Litigation Rankings with Eleven Attorneys HonoredBenchmark Litigation, 10.18.2021
- Hitting a New Milestone - 100 Members of Smith Anderson’s Legal Team Recognized by Best Lawyers® and Best Lawyers: Ones to WatchBest Lawyers, 08.19.2021
- Smith Anderson Shines in 2021 Chambers USA with Most Band 1 Practice Rankings of Any NC-Based Law FirmChambers USA, 05.21.2021
- Benchmark Litigation, 10.13.2020
- 2021 Best Lawyers® and The Best Lawyers: Ones to Watch Recognize Largest Group of Smith Anderson Lawyers in Firm’s HistoryThe 2021 Best Lawyers®, 08.20.2020
- Benchmark Litigation Honors Smith Anderson’s Litigation and Employment Litigation Groups and 12 LawyersBenchmark Litigation, 10.14.2019
- Smith Anderson Leads “Best Lawyers®” Rankings with 71 Recognized Lawyers and 11 “Lawyers of the Year” - Most of Any Raleigh Law FirmThe Best Lawyers in America©, 08.20.2019
- North Carolina Super Lawyers Recognizes Forty Smith Anderson Lawyers as Super Lawyers and Rising Stars in 2019Super Lawyers, 01.24.2019
- Benchmark Litigation, 10.16.2018
- The Best Lawyers in America©, 08.15.2018
- Chambers USA, 05.03.2018
- 2018 North Carolina Super Lawyers Recognizes Forty-three Smith Anderson Lawyers as Super Lawyers and Rising StarsSuper Lawyers, 01.25.2018
- Smith Anderson Litigators Explain the Shifting Trends in M&A Litigation Against U.S. Public CompaniesIR Update magazine, published by the National Investor Relations Institute, January/February Issue
- Benchmark Litigation, 10.03.2017
- The Best Lawyers in America©, 08.15.2017
- Chambers USA, 05.30.2017
- Super Lawyers, 01.20.2017
- Smith Anderson Assists in Advising British American Tobacco in Merger Agreement with Reynolds American01.17.2017
- 2017 The Best Lawyers in America© Guide Recognizes 62 Smith Anderson Lawyers – Most in the Firm’s History08.15.2016
- Chambers USA, 06.01.2016
- N.C. Lawyers Weekly, 02.29.2016
- 2016 The Best Lawyers in America© Guide Lists 60 Smith Anderson Lawyers – Most in the Firm’s History08.17.2015
- Smith Anderson Represents General Parts International in $2.04 Billion Merger with Advance Auto Parts03.18.2014
- Smith Anderson Announces 49 of its Firm Lawyers are Named a “Best Lawyer” by The Best Lawyers in America® 201308.29.2012
- Breaking: North Carolina Supreme Court Confirms that Dissenting Shareholders Are Entitled to No More than Deal Price in First Impression Merger Appraisal Rights Case12.22.2021
- Lawyers May Simultaneously Represent a Corporation and Its Directors Against Derivative Claims That Do Not Allege “Serious Wrongful Conduct”11.09.2021
- 07.28.2021Published by the American Bar Association I Practice Points
- Deal Price is King in Appraisal Rights Actions in North Carolina Where Merger Process Bears “Objective Indicia of Fairness”05.19.2020
- Another Tool in the Toolbox – Delaware Approves “Federal Forum Provisions” For Stockholder Securities Claims03.26.2020
- “Disclosure Settlements” Live On In North Carolina Merger Litigation – But Will the Fee Awards Continue to Justify Lawsuits?01.22.2018
- The Death of Merger Litigation Part II – The North Carolina Business Court Puts a Nail in the Coffin12.06.2016
- 08.08.2016Published by the American Bar Association, "Commercial & Business Section of Litigation" and "Corporate Counsel Section of Litigation"
- Tyranny of the Minority: North Carolina Business Court Explores Potential Fiduciary Duties of Minority Shareholders10.01.2015
- 03.2015Antitrust & Complex Business Dispute News (North Carolina Bar Association Antitrust & Complex Business Disputes Law Section Newsletter)
- Fourth Circuit Clarifies Pleading Standards and (Again) Rejects Affidavits that Contradict a Party’s Deposition03.16.2014
- North Carolina Business Court Limits Unfair and Deceptive Trade Practice Claims Concerning Internal Corporate Matters02.07.2014
- North Carolina Business Court Holds that Shareholders Cannot Directly Sue Officers and Directors in Merger Challenge11.22.2013
- Fourth Circuit Holds that Motor Carrier has No Claim Under Federal Law Against Shipper for Unpaid Freight Charges11.14.2013
- Moderator, “Issues in Business Organization Disputes” Panel at the 5th Annual NC Business Court CLE, Charlotte, N.C.05.2017
- Co-Presenter, "Swords and Shields: An Overview of Current Topics in Public Company Merger Litigation," UNC's Festival of Legal Learning, Chapel Hill, N.C.02.2016
- Presenter, "Getting into Business Court and Legislative Changes Affecting Business Court," NC Bar Association’s 2015 Antitrust & Complex Business Disputes Section Annual Meeting02.2015
Bar & Court Admissions
- Supreme Court of the United States
- U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit
- U.S. District Courts for the Eastern, Middle and Western Districts of North Carolina
- All North Carolina State Courts
- Admitted Pro Hac Vice in matters pending in various state and federal courts, including New York, South Carolina and Georgia
University of North Carolina, J.D., 1984
Duke University, B.A., magna cum laude, 1981